Road Funding Not Rational

-

A number of letters to the Southland Times have highlighted the frustration in the lack of regional balance in road funding and I decided to throw in my thoughts on the matter. This is something I have posted on before but is an ongoing issue. Considering that the Minister for Finance and the Assistant Speaker are our local MPs one would expect a greater level of advocacy on our behalf.

Dear Sir

I share the frustration of the many writers to this paper about the appalling lack of research and planning that is behind the current expenditure on New Zealand Roads.

This Government has committed to spending around $12 billion on 'Roads of National Significance' based on little more than the belief that they are a good idea. Most of these mainly North Island motorways do not even pass basic cost benefit analysis and are being pushed ahead despite traffic volumes stagnating (and will obviously continue to do so after the proposed increase in petrol tax).

Southland earns about 11% of our nation's export income despite having only 2% of the population. Surely it is commonsense to ensure that money spent on road infrastructure supports our economy rather than just keeping traffic flowing in major cities where public transport has been underfunded for decades.

When we have milk tankers rolling on poorly maintained roads and traffic held up for over an hour near our preeminent tourist resort there are serious economic consequences.

I would hope our local MPs are advocating strongly on our behalf to ensure that these issues are addressed in a timely fashion, however I do question their commitment to our region when there was no National Party representation at the economic debate held last month.

Let's make 2013 the year that Southland gets a fairer share of the economic pie that we generously contribute to.

Yours sincerely...

Comments

Evergreen said…
"... and traffic held up for over an hour near our preeminent tourist resort there are serious economic consequences."

"Holiday Highways" deserve no extra funding. We have been campaiging on this.
January 4, 2013 at 10:49 AM
Dave Kennedy said…
Evergreen, are you saying that we shouldn't support a new bridge at Frankton because it is no different from the Holiday Highway? If so I think there is a clear difference between replacing an historic one lane bridge causing disruption on a major tourist route that will cost $5-20 million to the $1.7 billion that will be spent on the 'Holiday Highway'.

There will be definite economic benefits from the Frankton bridge construction while the Holiday Highway fails cost benefit analysis:

http://www.nzta.govt.nz/network/projects/project.html?ID=170

http://tvnz.co.nz/national-news/doubts-worth-holiday-highway-4992534
January 4, 2013 at 11:09 AM
Evergreen said…
The people who buy our Holiday Highway line do not care about the economics, it is all about the placards, same as Asset Sales. But it makes it difficult if we have to try and explain ourselves, and explaining is losing, when we are shown to be inconsistent with our opposition to roading expenditure. Next thing we are backed into a corner over printing money, not by the people who will vote for us, but by some loud mouth in front of a group who then ridicule us. We have to stay firm on these things.
January 4, 2013 at 11:55 AM
Dave Kennedy said…
Evergreen, Julie Anne Genter has had much success questioning the justification for the RONs. For both the asset sales and the RONs the Greens have made progress by taking a rational economic stance and showing up National for not basing their policies on evidence. What is rattling the Government and their supporters are our solid economic arguments.

Also the Greens aren't against all roads just a lack of balance in the spending on roads compared to supporting other forms of transport. We don't want to promote a view that we are just anti-roads which is clearly an extreme view.

There is also a difference between managing a national campaign and dealing with regional issues. I have recieved much support as a Green activist in Southland by supporting our region's needs against the Governments biased agenda. As well as wanting a fairer distribution of funding for roading I have also campaigned for an improved rail service (there is no passenger train operating between Invercargill and Dunedin).

As the Greens become more prominent politically the level of attacks will also increase. I agree with you when you say that we have to stand firm but our stands should be rational ones.
January 4, 2013 at 12:21 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The US is actually unique for not valuing life!

-
Image
"...that’s what sets America apart from every other country; we value life. That is what makes us unique.” - Sarah Sanders There is a high level of delusion operating in the White House. The stream of mistruths that come out of President Trump and Sarah Sanders' mouths are clearly blatant lies but millions of US citizens believe them. With daily diets of Fox News and living in a very insular culture , there is little that challenges these false perceptions of US "greatness".  When comparing the United States of America with most other developed nations it becomes clear that it probably places less value on life than most and doesn't compare well with many developing countries too: If the US really valued life then it would abolish the death penalty, it is the only Western Country that executes people under law ( 23 people were executed in 2018 ).  If the US really valued life then it would have an equitable and universal health care system. The cur
Read more

The Destruction of New Zealand's Public Education System

-
Image
In 2008 New Zealand was internationally ranked in the top seven for educational achievement, and when you compared us with other countries that were also culturally diverse and experiencing growing inequality, we were extremely successful. At that time our Early Childhood sector had received a much overdue boost in funding from the Labour Government after being underfunded (as a % of GDP) compared to other OECD nations for years. The sector was working towards a target of having 100% qualified teachers in all centres. We were also in the process of implementing a new National Curriculum and a complementary curriculum for Maori ( Te Marautanga o Aotearoa ). Teachers were excited about putting all their energies into the new ideas and approaches that were espoused in these co-constructed documents that had taken around seven years to review and write. Evidence, research and practitioner input had created something that would allow us to prepare New Zealand children to become
Read more

ANZAC DAY REFLECTIONS

-
Image
I find ANZAC Day creates a dilemma for me, consequently I rarely attend dawn parades. I fully support people recognising the human cost of wars and remembering family members who lost their lives on battlefields. A grandfather of mine fought in WW1 and was gassed in the French trenches, which compromised his health for the rest of his life. His wife (my grandmother) lost her young brother in WW2. The sacrifices and human costs of war should never be minimalised. However, while speeches at ANZAC parades are full of statements promoting peace and the futility of war, those who campaign hardest for peace, promote nonviolence and call for weapons reductions are often treated like criminals. Anyone who dares to mention our own war crimes or that of our allies are generally shut down or demonised. It has become a sort of cultural heresy to question the reputation and glorification of the ANZACs.  I would love to see greater balance in how we talk about war and properly recognise those who ha
Read more