"Consumer" Recommendations Confounding
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a2308/a230814bbb8a25a1befc38cfe9d0d079744fba85" alt="Image"
I have always relied on Consumer's advice when buying major household items, however I have sometimes found their recommended buys don't live up to their status. The fridge we bought some years ago was a recommended model and yet we have been plagued by fluctuating temperatures and during Summer the fridge often turns into a freezer. When I pulled out our first cucumber of the season to use in a sandwich and found it was frozen solid, it was the last straw, especially after the strawberries I had picked the day before were in a similar state when I tried to put them on my breakfast cereal. Over the last few years we have had a succession of appliance specialists come in to try and fix the fridge and this time I decided that another costly repair (the fridge is well out of warranty) wasn't worth it, the fridge would have to go! I did look at the Consumer website, but rather than just going for their recommendations I also read the reviews that owners of the various mode...